What Are The Options Available For Your Old Plan?

Retirement planning is all about preparing for the future, but what happens when your old retirement plan from a previous employer is left hanging in the past? If you’ve changed jobs, you may still have an old 401(k) or another retirement account sitting with your former employer. While it might seem harmless to leave it as is, making the right move can impact your long-term financial health.
So, what are your options? Let’s explore the four smart choices you have when dealing with an old retirement plan.
________________________________________
1. Leave It Where It Is (If Possible)
The easiest and most hassle-free option is to leave your retirement savings where they are. In many cases, your former employer will allow you to keep your funds in their plan, provided you meet their minimum balance requirement (often around $5,000).
Why Leave Your 401(k) With Your Old Employer?
✅ Lower Fees – Some employer-sponsored plans have lower fees compared to individual retirement accounts (IRAs).
✅ Good Investment Options – If your former employer offers solid investment options with low fees, it might make sense to stay.
✅ Creditor Protection – 401(k) plans offer stronger protection from creditors than IRAs in many states.
Potential Downsides of Leaving It
❌ Limited Investment Choices – Many workplace plans have fewer investment options compared to an IRA.
❌ Difficulty Managing Multiple Accounts – If you change jobs frequently, managing multiple retirement accounts can become a hassle.
❌ Risk of Forgetting About It – The further removed you are from your old job, the easier it is to forget about your account.
Best for:
• Those who are happy with their current plan’s investment options and fees.
• Individuals who want the strongest creditor protection.
• Those who don’t mind managing multiple accounts.
________________________________________
2. Transfer to Your New Employer’s Plan (If Available)
If your new employer offers a 401(k) or similar retirement plan, rolling over your old account into your new one might be a great option.
Why Transfer Your 401(k) to a New Employer?
✅ Simplification – Consolidating accounts means fewer statements, easier tracking, and better overall management.
✅ Continued Tax Benefits – Your money stays in a tax-advantaged retirement account, avoiding penalties and taxes.
✅ Potential for Employer Match – Some employers allow you to roll in your old 401(k) balance, which might help with company match contributions (though not always).
Potential Downsides of Transferring
❌ Not All Employers Allow It – Some companies do not accept rollovers into their plans.
❌ May Have Higher Fees – Your new employer’s plan may have higher administrative or investment fees.
❌ Investment Limitations – Similar to keeping your old account, your new employer’s plan might not have the best investment choices.
Best for:
• Those who want to simplify their retirement savings.
• Individuals whose new employer offers strong investment options with low fees.
• People who want to keep all their retirement savings in one place.
________________________________________
3. Cash It Out (Not Recommended for Most People)
You always have the option to cash out your old 401(k), but this is usually the worst choice. Withdrawing your retirement funds early comes with major financial consequences.
Why Cashing Out Is Risky
❌ Taxes and Penalties – If you’re under 59½, you’ll pay a 10% early withdrawal penalty, plus income tax on the entire amount.
❌ Lost Growth Potential – Your retirement savings should grow over time. Cashing out means you miss out on decades of potential growth.
❌ Risk of Spending the Money – Once you take the money out, it’s easy to spend it on non-essential expenses instead of reinvesting it for retirement.
When Cashing Out Might Make Sense
🔹 Financial Emergency – If you have no other options and absolutely need the money, cashing out might be necessary.
🔹 Small Account Balances – If your balance is very low (a few hundred dollars), it might not be worth the hassle of transferring.
🔹 Severe Hardship Situations – Some plans allow penalty-free withdrawals in extreme hardship cases, but taxes still apply.
Best for:
• People facing extreme financial hardship.
• Those with a very small account balance.
• Anyone willing to pay the tax and penalty costs for immediate cash.
________________________________________
4. Rollover to an IRA (Best Choice for Many People)
Rolling your old 401(k) into an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) is often the best choice for long-term investors. An IRA typically offers more investment choices, lower fees, and greater flexibility than an employer-sponsored plan.
Why Choose an IRA Rollover?
✅ More Investment Options – IRAs typically offer a wider range of stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs.
✅ Lower Fees – Many IRAs have lower fees compared to some 401(k) plans.
✅ More Control – You get to decide where your money is invested, instead of relying on limited options in a workplace plan.
✅ Continued Tax Benefits – Your money stays in a tax-advantaged retirement account.
Potential Downsides of an IRA Rollover
❌ No Employer Match – Unlike a 401(k), an IRA doesn’t come with employer-matching contributions.
❌ Less Protection from Creditors – In some states, IRAs offer less legal protection from creditors than 401(k)s.
❌ Must Choose a Provider – You’ll need to select a brokerage firm or financial institution to open your IRA, which can take a bit of research.
Best for:
• Individuals who want more investment control and choices.
• Those looking to reduce fees.
• People who don’t need employer match contributions on rolled-over funds.
________________________________________
Which Option Is Right for You?
The best choice for your old retirement plan depends on your financial goals, job situation, and retirement timeline.
• If you want simplicity and don’t mind limited options, leaving it with your old employer might work.
• If your new employer offers a solid plan, transferring to your new 401(k) could make sense.
• If you want the most flexibility and control, rolling over to an IRA is probably your best bet.
• If you absolutely need the money, cashing out is an option, but it should be your last resort.
Taking the time to assess your options now can lead to better financial security in retirement. Don’t let your old retirement plan sit idle—make it work for you!
________________________________________
FAQs
1. What happens if I do nothing with my old 401(k)?
If you leave your old 401(k) untouched, it will continue to be invested. However, you might forget about it, and your former employer could change plan providers, making it harder to track.
2. Can I roll over a 401(k) into a Roth IRA?
Yes, but this is considered a Roth conversion, meaning you’ll owe taxes on the money you move. This can be a smart move if you expect your tax rate to be higher in retirement.
3. How long do I have to roll over my 401(k) after leaving a job?
There’s no deadline to roll over your 401(k), but if your former employer issues you a check, you have 60 days to deposit it into a new retirement account to avoid taxes and penalties.
4. What fees should I watch for when rolling over to an IRA?
Look out for account maintenance fees, investment expense ratios, and trading fees. Many online brokerages offer low-cost or no-fee IRAs.
5. Can I split my old 401(k) into multiple accounts?
Yes, you can roll over part of your 401(k) into an IRA while leaving some in your old or new employer’s plan. However, consider consolidation for easier management.